Kelas-Kelas Dian Nafi di Udemy
Alhamdulillah sudah ada 6 kelas bersama dian nafi di udemy
1. Menata Ulang Hidup
https://www.udemy.com/course/reset-your-life/
2. Writerpreneurship
https://www.udemy.com/course/writerpreneurship
Intro to Public Sector Economics
03/1
Mostly dealing with govt
Ministry, govt institution, etc
Definition
Public finance
Scope
Objective
Govt try to serve health, food, goods and services in this pandemic
Deal w regulation
Perpu no. 1
Hv pondation to run program
#PublicPolicy
Macro economic: fiscal, etc
Public intervention, deal w dailiy life
Ex taxes for income
Public revenue, how govt spent it
Comparing public and privat sector
Public sector produce based on country characteristic ex: bpjs
Good health system, education, infrastructure
Paradox between public vs private sector
Lack of transparancy
How govt react in easy &hard times
It become exam. govt can handle it?
Effecftiveness of govt intervention?
Everyone goes bankrupt now
Social security policy bansos
Public sector economi is a study
Finance, taxation
Public finance about how govt raise money to pay desired facility n service
Focus on microeconomic function of govt, affect allocation of resource and income distribution
Why there is still poor people
Lack of access to bigger market
Govt hard to find good income distribution
The rich have to pay more taxes
Pandemi become momentum for any govt
Chance for transformation to tech
Ground rules focus on basic
Regulatory background to promote it
Bpjs the key is to be patient
Bpjs card at second class should be changed. We hv to check items that we sign. The cost is the time
How KPI
After function
Compare how good management
Budget of ministry:there are many activities oct nov dec in order to absorbtion
Should objective
Indonesian development not equal on some areas
Desentralisation issuè
Management capability
System of reviewing is not proper
We need to improve it
Why money is there, switch posting to another is not easy
Good provision?
Neglect quality of the budget using
Biggest problem in indonesia is data
Good country ex: spore hv good data
Indonesian People is generous
They still pay bpjs even not get benefit
If we don't sign covid, hospital don't pay the bill
Trouble in indonesia,govt hv many cost for health but hospital not give correct data
Classic problem is faced by public sector in Indonesia
Some ministries spend money to conduct studies, consultant, etc
Sometimes they hv no expertise. Wasting money. Should be mechanism to save budget
Need to reform
Central govt use omnibus law to cut barriers in local area
Local govt capacity is important
Capacity building with workshop for local govt
But big bias if not effective, hv no access. There is gap between local govt and state govt
Taxes is main source of public revenue 60%
Some companies don't obey
Amnesti
Last data provided by social affairs ex: data terpadu 2015. 🤣
We have to update data twice a year to conduct and implement #publicpolicy
development progress can provide benefits for many people. But there are many cases of infrastructure development that seize people's land. Starting from the Kulon Progo case, the land grabbing of BIJB Majalengka,
the construction of a mine, a cement factory in Kendeng. Has an impact on the economic resources of the community in the village, the majority of which come from land.
Dana Bagi Hasil Cukai Hasil Tembakau (DBHCHT) is allocated to purchase hospital equipment. Where, on the other hand, there are many health campaigns against smoking. As at the national level, cover the BPJS with cigarette taxes
Musrenbangnas hv meeting and invite more stakeholders for spesific issues
government must have a KPI, Key Performance Indicator that includes of measuring integrity or in this case work performance
United States try to sue Indonesia to the World Trade Organization for dumping because it has significant effect to their nation income. Because the cigarette from United States Industry has loss it market in United States because of the Cigarette from Indonesia Industry (Kretek)
money.kompas.com/read/2019/10/14...
Gender equility?
Gender responsive budget
Consider on non techinical aspect
Need Implementation Strategy
In term of pandemic. Force majeur
How procedure to switch to allocate
Zakat mechanism for Institution
Confirmation
Dompet dhuafa has done it
What is the regulation
why there is differences in customs clearance process for the same goods?
it might be related to the declared "HS code" in the import declaration by PPJK. In the government's system, when you enter HS code, there will be information on tariff, import taxes and non-tariff barrier
such as SNI, specific licenses, ect. HS code is a self-assessment and a single good/item could be covered by different HS codes. If PPJK 1 use HS code A with 0% tariff and PPJK 2 use HS code B with 25% tariff then you will have a very significant cost difference.
Rather than bansos, maybe it's better to give such as a card, they may take money directly by themselves like ATM or use that card for getting staple food
Because the fact that, most of them are not need the staple food, they need money to pay other expenses
government had generalize what society wants. In the fact,they were wrong
In village, the people who take care of BANSOS get a lot of BENEFITS from CUTTING THE BUDGET such as buying eggs, TEMPE, and other basic necessities. If it's money, it's hard to be corrupted. yeah
Govt is unqualiffied when it comes to distribution and monitoring matter. They thought if the fund has been Given,their job is done
in fact, distribution of BANSOS still discriminative. only given to people who have ID card. Then, what about the vulnerable groups who don't have an ID card and they are affected by the pandemic?
pelaku seni has been informed from april that we will receive support fund in this pandemic, but we don't yet receive it until now (oct)
What the constraints of the distributions?
Is it just PHP?
ID card for the purpose of data record and report on statistic that will provide for many purpose for the government. Such as loan or funding.
Pragmatism is always appear in mind if we talk about diplomacy and policy
Spesific direction to follow US or china style?
Is it possible to combine zakat and tax?
If we give money assistance, at least the people know the exact amount of the assistance that they will get.
it's not only the data issue, it's related with the communication from bottom to top because the one that knows about the community very well is RT/RW level.
Classification of product is still not fix. Always changing
Most of feminist could start from the small thing
Communication and coordination is a big problem of our govt.
Sectoral ego. Ego sektoral.
Sailo. Selfish
HS code changing everytime and make us confusing as importer, the “communication” top down very important then
Public policy should be flexible and adaptive enough
Because there's so many changes and dynamics in reality life
Govt focus in development
But still have problem in equility
Issue on macro economic
Dealing w techocrat is very rigid,hard
They tent to slow adapting new thing
Ngaji Fiscal Policy
03/2
Musti konsentrasi. Ngaji fiscal policy soalnya. Allahumma zidnii ilman nafi'a warzuqni fahman wasi'a. Allahummarzuqna fahmannabiyin wa hifdzol mursaliin wa ilhamal malaikatil muqorrobiin birohmatika yaa arhamarrohimiin
Govt and roles Fiscal Policy instruments Fiscal policy as stabilization tool and its limitation Relation between fiscal policy and public debt Discussion
Govt role Program/policies Nawa cita 9 priorities long term dev prog rpjp 2025 Mid term dev prog rpjmn Strategic dev plan renstra
Fiscal policy consist Govt spending Taxes, transfer payment Keynes: G is most effective tool Great depression 1930 Global financial crisis GFC 2008
4 key roles fiscal policy Stabilizing macro economy Affecting income distribution Influencing disposable income Yd or Y-T through net tax (margin between tax paid n transfer payment received by household) Respond demographic change Manage public debt
Income distribution Fiscal policy influence distribution of income through Progressive tax Transfer payment
Measuring income inequality Lorenz curve Gini coefficient
If country have good income distribution, there's equality Lorenz curve is plotted for particular income distribution in economy Line of equality is benchmark case of perfectly equal distribution of income of economy
Numerical measure of income equality known as gini coefficient summarizes info contained in lorenz curve It is ratio of area between line of equality and lorenz curve to total area below the line of equality
Critic: supply sider view > need for tax cut > lower tax lead people to work harder, save more etc.
PROBLEM Of deficit Second consideration for fiscal policy maker thinking about stabilization policy is the need to avoid large n persistent budget deficit
Sustained govt budget deficit can be harmful>reduce national saving>reduce investment in new capital good (important source of long run economic growth) The need to keep deficit under control may make increasing spending or cutting tax, fight economic slowdown, less attractive option
How limitation be overcome Spend more on public capital/infrastructure Creating stable/conductive political condition
Relation between FP n public debt Govt hv 3 way to finance the spending Raise tax Borrow money Print money
Desirable level of public debt Low debt reduce crowding out Crowd out=situation when increased rate lead to reduction in private investment spending such that it reduce initial increase of total investment spending
Intergenerational equity Concept that current generation should not impose unfair burden on future Importance FP Presence automatic stabilizer Although FP difficult to change quickly, it may still be useful for dealing with prolonged episode of recession 1930 depression 1990 japan
Kartu Pra-Kerja supposed to be implemented in non-critical time like this. so the policy dealing with labor/worker's maternity leave(cuti hamil), and funeral leave is also part of fiscal policy? white collar are busy at the office saving their companies from being collapsed
everyone deserves payment based on their skills, i dont think there is a company who want to change the employer often. except to those who dont have skills, replaced easily. sad but true. tech has take over. u see the jalan tol, we use card ald
In this situation many tax payers is going to bankruptcy condition, and the raise of the tax in this condition will cause economic sectors in Indonesia collapsed.
it is sad to see some take cash for doing demo. seems that their health problems is not an issue for them
if we have good skills, company will pay us, no worry, but if we got no skills and we have a lot of demands, who want us to work as their employees? seems those who demand a lot, the skills are not directly proportional to their demand, so how can the investor listen to them,
while tech and robot can take over. it is happening round the world, artificial intelligence is taking over. AI and even physical bodied AI is taking over, seems like cyberpunk future is going to be a reality. welcome to blade runner 2020
Any limitation of how much maximum money that government will get from world bank/IMF? because the debt that indonesia have is getting escalade, and we don't know how to pay it back.
vietnam blue collar wage , minimum wage is around 2 juta by 2020. and vietnam is growing, i checked world bank to confirm then here, most blue collars are doing demo
true Vietnam's minimum wage is lower than here, but are the daily needs in Vietnam have lower price than Indonesia? Vietnam implement different political system from us, which is sosialist-communist. So, their government provide most of the things that their citizen need.
vietnam government is working hard to bring expenses down. hope indonesia government could compete with that
nice to hv govt provide things we need but not with freedom of speech Indonesian is better than socialist communist. maybe we can go back to Indonesia's history in Gerakan NonBlok It will be better than the socialist if there are no conglomerates disturb the policy making
with democracy people can be self-independent even the China is not totally socialist-communist They implement at politic, but for economic, they're not they open for foreign investment. in this globalization era, we couldn't stand alone to boost the economic growth
Prostitution business could also become alternative income Also casino. It happen before as at ancol and around.
the casino in Genting is not open for Malaysian citizens. They allowed foreigners to play at the casino
locals also gamble, entering it illegally before enter hall, we show ID. for Malaysian, they got prohibited china has reforms its economic system into capitalist. But it work though, socialist political system and capitalist economic system turns out can be in line together
make sure the systems can be in line together (Socialist Systems in Politics and Capitalist Systems in Economy), We need a strong govt (single political party system) Karl Marx might be shock with this reality (capitalist and socialist are complementary each other)
to face China's thread, we have to accelerate bureaucracy reform,etc the problem was not how Marx can topple the capitalist,but how cant Marxism can CONTROL the capitalist into developing national economy Karl Marx will make a revisions on his theory about economics n religion
single political party system means less disruption, less conflict, Orba did it with 3 party system, yet the corruption went rampant. :( to make sure the single party systems will run in line that need a strong figure that have strong influence in all over Indonesia.
Hello, my name is Dian Nafi. Founder of Hasfa Publishing & Institute